The one rule: the mods choose the loader
A mod loader is the layer that lets mods change the game. Each mod is built against one of them, so a Fabric mod won't load on Forge and a Forge mod won't load on Fabric. On a server the rule has a second half: the server and every player must run the same loader, the same Minecraft version and the same mods. Why plugins and mods are different things.
So the real question is rarely “which loader is best”. It's “which loader do the mods I want use?”. A modpack answers it on its own page; for a hand-picked set of mods, look at the loader each one lists.
Fabric, Forge and NeoForge, side by side
| Fabric | Forge | NeoForge | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | A modular, lightweight loader | The original loader | A fork of Forge, since July 2023 |
| Runs | Fabric mods | Forge mods | NeoForge mods (from 1.20.2, no longer the same as Forge's) |
| Also needs | Fabric API, for most mods | Nothing extra | Nothing extra |
| Where you'll meet it | Performance mods and lighter packs | Classic packs and older versions | Many recent big packs |
| RAM before any mod, in our calculator | 1.5 GB | 2 GB | 2 GB (sized like Forge) |
Fabric: light and modular
Fabric describes itself as a modular, lightweight mod loader. The loader on its own does very little: most mods also need Fabric API, a separate mod that goes in the mods folder like any other, and forgetting it is the most common reason a Fabric server won't start. In our experience, Fabric shines with performance mods and smaller packs.
Quilt is a fork of Fabric that presents itself as compatible with Fabric mods. It's in our software list too, but if a pack says Fabric, run Fabric.
Forge: the original
Forge is the loader most classic modpacks were built on, and its downloads go from the earliest Minecraft versions to the newest (26.3 when we checked). If your pack is for an older version, such as 1.12.2 or 1.7.10, Forge is usually the only option.
NeoForge: the fork most of the Forge team moved to
In July 2023, most of the Forge team forked the project as NeoForge. From its release for Minecraft 1.20.2 it uses its own package names and mod id, so mods are built for NeoForge or for Forge, not both. Many recent big packs run on NeoForge, which is why “Forge or NeoForge” is a real question for anything on 1.20.2 or later.
On 1.20.1, many packs still run on Forge. Whatever the version, read the pack's page and run exactly the loader it names.
How much RAM each one needs
The loader sets the floor and the mods do the rest: every mod loads its blocks, items and recipes before anyone joins. These are the estimates from our calculator, which sizes NeoForge like Forge:
| Your server | RAM to start with | Plan that fits | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fabric, 30 mods, 5 players | 3.5 GB | $6.00/month | |
| Fabric, 100 mods, 10 players | 6 GB | $9.00/month | |
| Forge or NeoForge, 100 mods, 5 players | 7 GB | $12.00/month | |
| Forge or NeoForge, 200 mods, 10 players | 11.5 GB | $18.00/month | |
| Forge or NeoForge, 300 mods, 20 players | 16.5 GB | $30.00/month |
With a big pack, the mods weigh far more than the loader: the gap between Fabric and Forge matters for light setups, not for a 300-mod pack. If the pack recommends a number, trust it. How much RAM a Minecraft server needs.
How to choose, in three questions
Is it a modpack?
Then it already chose: its page names the loader and the Minecraft version. Run those, with the pack's server files. Running a modpack server.
Which version do you want to play?
Older versions such as 1.12.2 mean Forge. For the newest ones, check which loaders your must-have mods already support.
Which mods can't you live without?
List them, check each mod's page for its loader and version, and pick the loader they share. If one big mod exists for only one loader, that decides it.
Running it on our panel
Fabric, Forge, NeoForge and Quilt are all in the software list when you order, and the panel's mod and modpack installers add mods without FTP. Changing the loader later means a new set of mods, because a mod built for one loader won't load on another: take a backup first.
If you remember one thing
Don't pick a loader, read it: the modpack or your must-have mods already chose. Fabric for light, modular setups; Forge for older versions and classic packs; NeoForge for many recent big packs on 1.20.2 and later.
Questions people ask
No. Each mod is built for one loader. Some mods publish a separate version for each loader: download the one for the loader your server runs.
It started as a fork of Forge in July 2023. From Minecraft 1.20.2 it has its own package names and mod id, so mods are built for one or the other.
Fabric is lighter on its own: our calculator counts 1.5 GB for a Fabric server before any mod, against 2 GB for Forge and NeoForge. With big packs, the mods weigh far more than the loader.
The world file stays, but the mods don't carry over, and blocks from mods that aren't on the new loader disappear. Back up first, and treat it as a new modded world unless the same mods exist for both.
About this article: It comes from what I have learned running EnduranceNodes, and it is published here first. We sell Minecraft hosting, so everything I say about us can be checked on this site, and I point out where we are not the best fit.